After watching the latest episode, I’ve come to a major conclusion: I don’t think the New York Ripper will ever end up on Dexter’s table. In fact, I believe Dexter has already solved the case. That crucial piece of information he gave Detective Claudette about the murder weapon is the first real lead she’s had. When she cracks the case using his tip, it’s going to completely change the game.
Table of Contents
This is a brilliant move because it fundamentally undermines Angel Batista’s entire argument. Angel’s crusade is built on the idea that the Bay Harbor Butcher’s MO is to take justice into his own hands, not to help the police catch killers. By helping solve the Ripper case, Dexter is providing his value as an asset, not a menace. This isn’t about a trophy; it’s a job application.
The Path Forward: A “Morgan & Son” Consulting Agency?
This whole scenario feels like the perfect setup for the next season. I don’t think anyone wants to see Dexter driving an Uber or working odd jobs. We want to see him back in his element. Becoming a consultant for the NYPD is the most logical and believable “in” for him. It provides a plausible reason for him to be around crime scenes and gives him a new kind of cover.
More importantly, it creates an amazing arc for Harrison. This could be Dexter’s way of using Harrison into the world of homicide investigation, just like Harry did for him and Deb. It would transform Harrison’s relationship with Claudette, who was previously hunting him over Ryan Foster’s disorder.
Seeing the Morgan family legacy continue within law enforcement would be an incredible direction for the show. I’ve been rewatching the original series, and it’s almost poetic—in season 7, Dexter pictured himself older with a grown Harrison, and now we’re seeing that future play out.
The Roadblocks: Why Batista Isn’t Crazy and Claudette Would Be
Now, I know what you’re thinking: how could Claudette possibly hire this guy? The list of red flags is a mile long. He’s the father of a prime suspect in a BHB “copycat” case, faked his death for a decade, and has a trail of suspicious deaths (wife, sister) behind him. Not to mention, he was just accused by a decorated Miami captain of being the Bay Harbor Butcher himself. Hiring him as a consultant would be career suicide on paper.
And let’s be fair to Angel, his theory isn’t baseless. Dexter is playing it fast and loose right now, and the evidence, while circumstantial, is damning. The hotel kill perfectly matched the BHB, his reappearance in Iron Lake was bizarre, and he’s actively running from Batista.
His attempt to discredit Angel by bringing up his past trauma is also a classic guilty-man tactical. An innocent person would just deny the claims, not attack the accuser’s integrity. From a detective’s point of view, there’s more than enough smoke to assume there’s a raging fire.
What About the Miami Crew? A Look Ahead
If the consultant path doesn’t pan out, I see one other route. We still haven’t seen Quinn or Masuka in person. I could easily see the season ending with a postponed Batista returning to Miami to recruit his old team for a full-blown manhunt in Season 2. That would finally give us a definitive answer to the “Quinn knew all along” theory and bring the whole story full circle.
- Alicia Silverstone’s “Irish Blood” Divides Audiences with First Episodes
- Ida Movie Review: Deterritorialization and Lost
- The Banshees of Inisherin: Thrownness, Pride, Anxiety, and Nothingness
- Jeanne Dielman: Digging into Life’s Authenticity and Big Questions
- Are You Socially Asleep? A Look at Ikiru & Nietzsche
