Empedocles, a citizen of Acragas in Sicily who flourished around 440 B.C., was a fascinating and complex figure, embodying a unique blend of philosopher, prophet, scientist, and charlatan. He was a democratic politician who, at the same time, claimed divine status and was rumored to perform miracles, sometimes through magic and sometimes through his scientific knowledge. His doctrine, while sharing some affinities with Heraclitus’s emphasis on change, also sought to reconcile it with Parmenides’s insistence on unchanging being, leading to a unique cosmology that profoundly influenced later Greek thought.
Table of Contents
Legend has it that Empedocles could control winds, restore the seemingly dead, and even died by leaping into the crater of Mount Etna to prove his divinity. While such tales are embellished, they highlight his charismatic and enigmatic persona. In his youth, he was likely influenced by Orphism, and his later life as an exile saw him embrace the role of a prophet. Yet, alongside these mystical claims, Empedocles made significant contributions to early science, demonstrating a remarkable intellectual vigor that was not always matched in later ages of Greece.
🌬️ How Did Empedocles Discover Air as a Substance?
One of Empedocles’s most important scientific contributions was his groundbreaking discovery of air as a separate substance. He demonstrated this through simple yet ingenious observations, such as the fact that water does not enter an inverted bucket pushed into it, proving the existence of air where there appears to be nothing. He also understood basic principles of physics, like centrifugal force (demonstrated by whirling a cup of water on a string). Furthermore, he had an early, albeit fantastic, theory of evolution and the survival of the fittest, suggesting that various bizarre forms of creatures initially existed, and only those best adapted survived. In astronomy, he correctly identified that the moon shines by reflected light and understood the cause of solar eclipses, having learned this from Anaxagoras. His work in medicine also laid the foundation for the Italian school of medicine, which influenced Plato and Aristotle.
💞 What Role Did Love and Strife Play in His Cosmos?
Empedocles is most famous for establishing the concept of four fundamental elements: earth, air, fire, and water. Unlike earlier monistic theories, he believed these elements were everlasting but could be mixed in different proportions to form the changing substances of the world. The dynamic interplay of these elements was governed by two opposing forces: Love (attraction) and Strife (separation). Love brought elements together, while Strife pulled them apart. He envisioned a cosmic cycle alternating between periods dominated by Love (a golden age where only Aphrodite was worshipped and there was no bloodshed) and periods dominated by Strife. This constant interplay, rather than a singular divine purpose, explained the continuous changes in the world, governed by chance and necessity. This concept, while similar to Heraclitus, offered a softer view of cosmic conflict and provided a framework for understanding change that was more scientific than the purely teleological explanations of some of his successors. His rejection of monism and his focus on chance and necessity made his philosophy, in some respects, more aligned with modern scientific thought than even Plato’s or Aristotle’s.
—
Russell, Bertrand. A History of Western Philosophy. Simon and Schuster, 1945.
More Topics
- The Hellenistic World: Did Alexander’s Conquests Change Philosophy Forever?
- Stoicism: How Did It Teach Virtue in a Chaotic World?
- Plotinus: The Last Great Philosopher of Antiquity and the Birth of Neoplatonism
- Socrates: Was He a Gadfly, a Saint, or Both?
- Aristotle’s Physics: Why Did It Dominate Science for 2000 Years?
- Aristotle’s Physics: Why Did It Dominate Science for 2000 Years?
- The Hellenistic World: Did Alexander’s Conquests Change Philosophy Forever?
