One of the most controversial and fascinating concepts in the history of political thought is the ‘noble lie’ from Plato’s *Republic*. To understand Plato’s vision for a just city, it is essential to learn how to analyze the ‘noble lie’ not as a simple deception, but as a complex political tool. This foundational myth, or *gennaion pseudos*, is designed to create social harmony and persuade citizens to accept their place within a structured and hierarchical society. It reveals Plato’s deep understanding of the power of narrative in shaping political reality.
Table of Contents
🌱 The Myth of the Earthborn: Fostering Civic Unity
The first part of the noble lie is the myth of autochthony, which tells the citizens that they are all ‘earthborn’ brothers, sprung from the soil of their own land. The purpose of this tale is to foster a powerful sense of civic unity and fraternity. By believing they are all siblings from the same mother (the earth), citizens are more likely to care for one another and for the land they inhabit. This story erases the memory of their actual, diverse origins and replaces it with a shared, sacred foundation, binding them together as a single family and encouraging them to defend their city as they would their own mother.
🥇 The Myth of the Metals: Justifying Social Hierarchy
The second, and more controversial, part of the myth is the ‘myth of the metals.’ The story goes that when the god fashioned the citizens, he mixed different metals into their souls. The rulers (or guardians) have gold in their souls, the auxiliaries (soldiers) have silver, and the farmers and craftsmen have bronze or iron. This allegory is designed to justify the city’s rigid, three-tiered social structure. It presents the natural inequality of talents and aptitudes as a divine and unchangeable fact, encouraging citizens to accept their designated roles without resentment and to perform their duties for the good of the whole city.
🤔 A Tool of Persuasion, Not Just Deception
While the term ‘lie’ carries negative connotations, Plato presents it as a medicinal or useful falsehood, a necessary tool for political founding. For Plato, the noble lie is a form of political mythmaking intended to communicate a deeper truth through a fictional narrative. The ‘truth’ is that people have different natural capacities, and a just city is one where each person performs the role for which they are best suited. Because most people cannot grasp this through philosophical reasoning, the myth provides a more persuasive and accessible way to achieve the same harmonious outcome.
—
Keum, Tae-Yeoun. Plato and the Mythic Tradition in Political Thought. The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2020.
More Topics
- How Later Thinkers Used Plato’s Mythic Tradition
- How to Interpret the Myth of Er in Plato’s Republic
- How to Understand the Myth of Atlantis as a Political Allegory
- How to Understand Plato’s Use of Myths in Political Philosophy
- Hannah Arendt: Who Asked You to Believe?
- Was Hannah Arendt a 20th-Century Genius?
- Giorgio Agamben – On Architect and Dwelling
