“The Banshees of Inisherin” is a masterful film that can be viewed as a deep, critical engagement with the philosophy of Martin Heidegger. The movie’s strength lies in its portrayal of the absurd and potentially hollow nature of pursuing a purely “authentic” life.
The Heideggerian Path to Authenticity
The analysis begins with Heidegger’s concept of authenticity. This isn’t simply originality; it’s a state of being achieved through a specific condition: anxiety. This philosophical anxiety forces individuals to confront their own solitude and mortality.
This confrontation with death leads to an encounter with nothingness. According to Heidegger, facing this void frees a person from the pressures of societal categories—like career or marriage—allowing them to create their own meaning and live authentically.
Colm’s Quest and Its Dark Side
In the film, Colm embodies this Heideggerian quest. He seeks a timeless legacy through his music, cutting himself off from what he deems dull social norms. His shocking act of cutting off his own finger is a radical attempt to achieve a sacred status, a way to punish his worldly self to reach for something eternal.
However, the film argues that this journey backfires. Instead of reaching a higher state, Colm becomes more self-absorbed, filled with pride, ambition, and contempt for others.
The Film’s Core Critique: The Emptiness Within
The genius of “The Banshees of Inisherin” is that it questions the very value of this journey. It asks: what is actually found at the end of this quest for authenticity?
For Colm, the answer seems to be nothing more than his own negative traits. His deep dive into his own being reveals a hollow core. This suggests that the noble “journey into the self” might not be a path to enlightenment, but a slide into profound selfishness. The film reinforces this by showing Pádraic, the “simple” man, also descending into hatred and vengeance, suggesting both paths can lead to the same darkness.
The Island of “Thrownness”
The film’s setting is a powerful metaphor. The desolate, forgotten island mirrors Heidegger’s concept of “thrownness” —the idea that humans are thrown into the world, alone and abandoned, and forced to find meaning. The characters’ deep loneliness is a perfect illustration of this existential condition.
Ultimately, the film is a brilliant piece of work not because it perfectly illustrates Heidegger’s ideas, but because it dares to show their potential absurdity and failure in practice.
More Topics
- What is Alavism: Suuni or Shia?
- What Was Wittgenstein’s Main Idea: Ideas, Legacy, and Key Questions
- Shrek and Maurice Tillet: An Uncanny Connection
- The Secret to Jordan Peterson’s Debate Strategy: It’s All a Word Game
- Thucydides was a Woke or Putin?
- The First Walking Dead: Social Collapse During the Plague of Athens
- Thucydides’s Trap: How an Ancient War Explains the Modern US-China Conflict
