While the thirteenth century marked the zenith of the medieval Catholic synthesis, the fourteenth century ushered in a period of profound disintegration, particularly for the papacy. Various forces, both political and cultural, combined to diminish the Church’s once-unquestioned authority, leading to a rapid transformation in European society and thought.
The Byzantine Empire’s conquest by the Latins in 1204 and its subsequent loss to the Pope in 1261, along with the defeat of the Western Empire in its conflict with the papacy, proved to be pyrrhic victories for the Church. These events, coupled with the rise of powerful national monarchies in France and England, meant that the Pope’s temporal power and spiritual influence began to wane, especially north of the Alps.
A major contributing factor was the rise of a rich commercial class and the increasing knowledge among the laity. Italian cities, particularly in the North, became centers of wealth and learning, fostering a spirit of independence that often turned against the Pope once the Emperor ceased to be a menace. This new lay culture, with its growing intellectual and economic power, challenged the traditional clerical monopoly on knowledge and authority.
The papacy, which had become increasingly worldly and focused on revenue collection, appeared more as a taxing agency than a spiritual guide. It drew vast sums from across Catholic Europe that many nations now wished to retain at home. This growing resentment, coupled with the popes’ diminished moral authority, set the stage for widespread discontent.
🇫🇷 The Avignon Papacy and the Great Schism
The papacy’s decline became dramatically apparent with Boniface VIII (1294-1303). Despite making extreme claims of papal supremacy, he faced a violent conflict with King Philip IV of France over the taxation of the French clergy. Philip’s successful defiance led to Boniface’s arrest and eventual death. This marked a turning point, as subsequent popes, for a long time, dared not oppose the King of France.
In 1309, Clement V, a Gascon, settled the papacy in Avignon, France, where it remained for about seventy years, effectively becoming a political subordinate of the French king. This “Babylonian Captivity” of the papacy severely damaged its universal prestige.
The situation worsened with the Great Schism (1378-1417), where two (and later three) rival popes claimed legitimacy, each supported by different European powers. This scandal further eroded the papacy’s moral authority and highlighted the need for a power superior to even a legitimate pope.
📚 The Conciliar Movement and Wycliffe’s Challenge
The Conciliar Movement emerged as a response to the Great Schism, advocating for the supremacy of a General Council over the Pope. Councils like Pisa (1409) and Constance (1414) attempted to heal the schism and reform the Church, even deposing popes and electing new ones.
While the Council of Constance successfully ended the schism, the movement ultimately failed to establish a constitutional monarchy for the papacy, as subsequent popes reasserted their absolute authority. However, the movement’s ideas, particularly the notion of a council’s superiority, found fertile ground for later reforms.
Simultaneously, figures like John Wycliffe (c. 1320-1384), an Oxford scholar and secular priest, directly challenged papal authority and traditional Church doctrines. Driven by moral outrage at clerical wealth and corruption, Wycliffe argued that unrighteous clergy had no title to their property and that the civil power should decide on ecclesiastical matters.
He translated the Vulgate into English and established “poor priests” to preach directly to the populace, bypassing the corrupt clergy. His doctrines, though severely persecuted, led to the Lollard movement in England and influenced Jan Hus in Bohemia. In doing so, they kept the revolt against the papacy alive and prepared the soil for the Reformation in the sixteenth century.
The eclipse of the papacy in this period fundamentally altered the balance of power in Europe, paving the way for the rise of national states and the eventual fragmentation of Christendom.
—
Russell, Bertrand. A History of Western Philosophy. Simon and Schuster, 1945.
More Topics
- The Thirteenth Century: A Zenith of Medieval Power and Intellectual Ferment?
- Thomas Aquinas: How Did He Harmonize Aristotle with Christian Faith?
- Beyond Aquinas: What Did Franciscan Thinkers Add to Medieval Philosophy?
- The Papacy’s Rise: How Did It Navigate the Chaos of the Dark Ages?
- John the Scot: Was He a Rebel Philosopher in the Dark Ages?
- The Church’s Revival: How Eleventh-Century Reforms Sparked Papal Power?
- The Golden Age of Islam: How Did Muslim Scholars Preserve Ancient Philosophy?
