The Reformation and Counter-Reformation represent a tumultuous period in European history, fundamentally reshaping its religious, political, and intellectual landscape.
At its core, this era was a rebellion of less civilized northern nations against the intellectual domination of Italy, which had spearheaded the Renaissance. For the Reformation, this revolt was multifaceted, encompassing political and theological dimensions as it rejected papal authority and the vast tribute extracted by Rome.
The Counter-Reformation, conversely, was a reaction against the intellectual and moral freedoms of Renaissance Italy, aiming to reassert papal power and enforce a stricter orthodoxy.
The three towering figures of this transformative period were Martin Luther, John Calvin, and Ignatius Loyola. Intellectually, Luther and Calvin, the architects of the Protestant Reformation, represented a return to a more medieval philosophy. They particularly drew from Saint Augustine’s teachings on the soul’s direct relationship with God, while largely discarding his emphasis on the Church’s institutional role.
They abolished purgatory and rejected the doctrine of indulgences, thereby significantly diminishing the financial and spiritual power of the papacy. Their doctrine of predestination rendered the fate of the soul after death independent of priestly actions, fundamentally altering the relationship between the individual and the divine.
While Protestant clergy were initially as dogmatic as their Catholic counterparts, the rise of national Churches in Protestant countries ultimately led to greater freedom of speculation, as these national entities lacked the international power to control secular governments.
⚔️ Loyola and the Jesuit Counter-Attack
The initial, astonishingly rapid success of Protestantism was dramatically checked by Ignatius Loyola’s creation of the Jesuit order. Founded on military models, the Jesuits were characterized by unquestioning obedience to their General, viewing themselves as soldiers in a relentless war against heresy. They quickly became influential, notably at the Council of Trent, and proved to be disciplined, able, and highly skilled propagandists.
Their theology directly opposed Protestant doctrines, emphasizing free will and rejecting predestination, asserting that salvation came through both faith and works. The Jesuits gained immense prestige through their missionary zeal, particularly in the Far East, and became popular as confessors due to their perceived leniency (except towards heresy).
Their focus on education allowed them to exert a firm hold on the minds of the young, and their political influence, often in the wake of conquering Spanish armies, led to the re-establishment of the Inquisition’s terror even in Italy, which had previously enjoyed a century of free thought.
The intellectual consequences of the Reformation and Counter-Reformation were initially detrimental, leading to a period of philosophical barrenness. The Thirty Years’ War, a devastating conflict fueled by religious divisions, ultimately forced a reluctant abandonment of the medieval hope for doctrinal unity.
This widespread exhaustion with theological warfare redirected the attention of able minds towards secular learning, especially mathematics and science. The diversity of creeds across different countries also provided an avenue for escaping persecution by relocating.
These factors collectively contributed to the philosophical resurgence of the seventeenth century, which witnessed unprecedented advancements in science and laid the groundwork for modern philosophy. This demonstrates how even profound religious conflict can, in the long run, inadvertently foster intellectual freedom and progress.
Source: Russell, Bertrand. A History of Western Philosophy. Simon and Schuster, 1945.
More Topics
- John Dewey: Instrumentalism and the Evolution of Truth
- The Utilitarians: Can Happiness Be Quantified and Legislated?
- Karl Marx: The Philosopher of History, Class, and Revolution
- Bergson: The Philosopher of Life, Intuition, and Creative Evolution
- William James: Radical Empiricism and the ‘Will to Believe’
- Locke’s Theory of Knowledge: How Did Empiricism Challenge Innate Ideas?
- Locke’s Political Philosophy: How Did He Justify Government by Consent?
